July 23, 2024

Democracy in Crisis: The Threat of Another Trump Term

Chapters

00:00 - Threat of Second Trump Term

03:47 - Call to Action Against Trumpism

11:49 - Toxicity of MAGA Rhetoric and Violence

21:10 - Trump's Impact on Democratic Institutions

25:16 - Supreme Court Vacancy Battles and Rulings

28:53 - Trump's Threat to Democracy

35:37 - Protecting Democracy Against Autocracy

40:29 - Threats to Democracy

Transcript
WEBVTT

00:00:00.320 --> 00:00:03.710
Democracies fall or slide towards autocracy all the time.

00:00:03.710 --> 00:00:08.250
It is our job as citizens to protect our democracy if we want to keep it.

00:00:08.250 --> 00:00:21.120
Welcome back to the United she Stands podcast, the show that brings kindness and women into politics.

00:00:21.501 --> 00:00:31.928
I'm Ashley and I'm Sarah and we're two women from Ohio who are here to become more educated about American politics and build a community so we can all get involved and make an impact together.

00:00:32.560 --> 00:00:34.801
We hope we'll inspire and empower you along the way.

00:00:34.801 --> 00:00:52.491
Hello everyone, and welcome back to another episode of the United she Stands podcast.

00:00:52.491 --> 00:01:11.962
We are going to dive into a topic that is so, so important and maybe it seems obvious, and that is why a second Trump term is a threat to our democracy, and we are recording this on July 17th, that is, four days after the attempted assassination on Donald Trump, but we did have this episode planned for this date well before this most recent event.

00:01:11.962 --> 00:01:24.206
However, with the recent events, we obviously had to add to this episode, and we have to start this episode now by saying that our hearts truly go out to the families and all those in Butler County that were impacted by this act of violence.

00:01:24.206 --> 00:01:26.870
Violence has no place in politics.

00:01:26.870 --> 00:01:29.614
It has no place in our schools or our communities either.

00:01:29.614 --> 00:01:40.260
Yet, unfortunately, as Americans, we see it all the time and we are going to talk more about this later, but the point here is that we absolutely denounce all forms of violence, as all Americans really should.

00:01:40.260 --> 00:01:45.153
So, with all that said, it does not change our plan to record or release this episode.

00:01:45.579 --> 00:01:50.262
Explaining the ways that Donald Trump is a threat to democracy does not equate to calling for violence.

00:01:50.262 --> 00:01:57.867
The things he does and says have to be addressed, and they can and should be addressed in a way that shares information and truth without inciting violence.

00:01:57.867 --> 00:02:01.022
I would argue that this is what most folks have been doing.

00:02:01.022 --> 00:02:04.347
Trump and team are, of course, going to try to spin this and act like.

00:02:04.347 --> 00:02:13.451
The majority of hateful and extremely divisive, violent inciting rhetoric comes from his opponents or those who speak out against him, but the reality is that it's just not true.

00:02:13.451 --> 00:02:16.729
We have receipts, honestly, on all the different ways.

00:02:16.729 --> 00:02:24.073
Donald Trump is one of the main people and one of the major driving forces to the rhetoric in this country that does and has incited violence.

00:02:24.073 --> 00:02:34.912
He is trying to rewrite this narrative now where, if you say he is threatening democracy or if you share the parallels to how other fascist leaders rise to power with what he's doing, then you're the one inciting violence.

00:02:34.912 --> 00:02:42.389
Ultimately, this is just a ploy to silence folks like us and everyone else out there from calling him on the things he has done, said and plans to do.

00:02:43.252 --> 00:02:54.068
So, all that said, we can denounce violence and we absolutely do and we can talk about how mega extremists have helped put us in this position as a nation that is backsliding when it comes to our democracy.

00:02:54.068 --> 00:03:02.324
We can talk about the plans they have that are undemocratic, and we can, and we must still call Trump and team on the awful things they say, do and are planning to do.

00:03:02.324 --> 00:03:13.606
So back to the topic we had planned, which is still just as relevant, if not more relevant, and that is the threat Donald Trump does impose on our democracy as a candidate, and especially if he gets a second term.

00:03:13.606 --> 00:03:27.110
Like I said, maybe it's obvious to us, maybe it's obvious to you, but I personally know that I can't have trouble articulating just how bad things will be if he gets into office, when talking among friends and family, and especially if that conversation gets passionate.

00:03:27.110 --> 00:03:34.062
So we took the time to lay it out in an organized fashion, with some facts, data and examples, so we could better speak on it in the upcoming months.

00:03:34.586 --> 00:03:45.967
We're hoping sharing it with you today in a thoughtful way will help you better articulate all the reasons this man is so incredibly unfit to be our president and how significantly altered or diminished we may see our democracy if he gets back into office.

00:03:45.967 --> 00:03:47.810
Ready, sarah?

00:03:47.810 --> 00:03:50.112
I don't know, man.

00:03:50.112 --> 00:03:51.980
I know we haven't even started yet.

00:03:51.980 --> 00:03:53.264
I feel like I already have to take a breath.

00:03:53.264 --> 00:03:59.830
So, before officially diving in, what are we drinking today, sarah, and maybe tell me it's something strong to get us through it.

00:04:00.241 --> 00:04:02.585
Oh, I am absolutely telling you it's something strong.

00:04:02.585 --> 00:04:06.834
I have a nice seafoam from the one and only Jackie O's.

00:04:06.834 --> 00:04:09.408
It's a 7%, so it's quite up there.

00:04:09.408 --> 00:04:16.011
Honestly, I was looking through the beer in my fridge and this is the lowest percentage beer that I have left.

00:04:16.011 --> 00:04:19.571
So, honestly, it fits very well for today's topic.

00:04:19.571 --> 00:04:22.490
We're going to need a little extra something to get us through.

00:04:22.490 --> 00:04:24.988
Maybe go to beer number two, just depends.

00:04:24.988 --> 00:04:26.805
We'll see how it flows.

00:04:26.805 --> 00:04:27.963
Ash, what?

00:04:27.983 --> 00:04:28.586
are you drinking?

00:04:28.586 --> 00:04:32.007
Well, I said, make it strong, and I'm drinking a non-alcoholic beer.

00:04:32.007 --> 00:04:33.692
So I did the opposite.

00:04:33.692 --> 00:04:39.365
But I was on vacation last week Well, not really, I was traveling, I should say better and I drank a lot.

00:04:39.365 --> 00:04:42.209
So I just need a minute of a break, but need a minute of a break.

00:04:42.209 --> 00:04:46.391
But we did get some really cool beer that we brought back from Wisconsin, so this is one of those.

00:04:46.391 --> 00:04:52.997
It's from entitled, untitled art, which they do like really good fruited sours, and Nick got a couple packs of their non-alcoholic.

00:04:52.997 --> 00:04:58.488
So I'm drinking their mango dragon fruit and a fruited sour, so nice.

00:04:58.930 --> 00:05:00.874
It'll be like the placebo effect You'll like.

00:05:00.874 --> 00:05:03.363
It's like you know, it tastes like beer.

00:05:03.363 --> 00:05:07.411
You're going to need that to get through and yeah, it'll be fine.

00:05:07.411 --> 00:05:09.516
Yeah, exactly, okay.

00:05:09.516 --> 00:05:26.130
So, before we do anything today, we want to touch on who we will be supporting in the 2024 presidential election, and maybe you've guessed based on the episode topic today or the introduction Ash gave or our many social media posts, but we want to lay it out super clearly for everyone.

00:05:26.130 --> 00:05:32.524
Our goal is to be a place where people can come to learn and not a place where we tell you how to vote or who to vote for.

00:05:32.524 --> 00:05:35.754
But we just can't do that in this election.

00:05:36.317 --> 00:05:41.050
We will be advocating for a specific candidate and we will be advocating with all we have for them.

00:05:41.050 --> 00:05:46.103
The Republican Party as folks used to know it before Donald Trump, is just no more.

00:05:46.103 --> 00:05:49.274
It hasn't been for years and we must accept that.

00:05:49.274 --> 00:06:02.783
We're not saying all Republican elected officials are MAGA Republicans, but the political party itself, meaning the folks that run the show, and therefore a lot of the elected officials in prominent positions, are now MAGA Donald Trump Republicans.

00:06:02.783 --> 00:06:05.110
The days of Reagan and Bush are over.

00:06:05.980 --> 00:06:10.286
The rhetoric, the divisiveness, the hatred, the blatant threat to democracy.

00:06:10.286 --> 00:06:12.348
We cannot stand for any of it.

00:06:12.348 --> 00:06:28.413
Donald Trump and the current GOP leadership is a very serious threat to our democracy and, to be clear, when we say threat, we mean a threat that we have to deal with by sharing information about it and helping folks understand what they are doing and their agenda so we can defeat them at the ballot in November.

00:06:28.413 --> 00:06:39.552
But we will not soften that message, we will not partake in hate speech or dehumanize Trump or his supporters, but we will call the situation for exactly what it is, with examples and data.

00:06:39.552 --> 00:06:52.156
There are so many parallels to the messaging and actions him and MAGA Republicans have taken in the past decade, especially the past five years to Hitler, mussolini and other fascists that rose to power.

00:06:52.156 --> 00:07:08.369
Just some fun little examples here include undermining our democratic processes, like our elections, with false accusations of fraud, dehumanizing and demonizing fellow Americans who do not support him by calling them rodents, infestations, etc.

00:07:08.369 --> 00:07:12.302
Attacking the objective truth and creating his own version of reality.

00:07:12.302 --> 00:07:19.146
Attacking and undermining the media, embracing extreme nationalism and, honestly, the list goes on.

00:07:19.300 --> 00:07:22.269
I think the point has been made.

00:07:22.269 --> 00:07:26.350
We tell you all this to say we don't care who the Democratic nominee is.

00:07:26.350 --> 00:07:30.271
That is who we're going to be supporting and urging everyone to support this election.

00:07:30.271 --> 00:07:34.007
Not third party because you think Biden isn't great or too old.

00:07:34.007 --> 00:07:39.295
Not holding back a vote for Biden because we don't like the way he's handled Gaza or some of the things he's done.

00:07:39.295 --> 00:07:46.613
We must vote Democratic, whether it's Biden or not, if we want our country to still be a place of Democratic values in 2025.

00:07:46.613 --> 00:07:51.291
We must think long term and not be short-sighted for just the next four years.

00:07:51.821 --> 00:07:56.067
There is a clear difference between these two parties at this point, and I will just say I'm not a party girl.

00:07:56.067 --> 00:07:58.206
Come on, that's funny.

00:07:58.206 --> 00:07:59.980
But seriously, I beg to differ.

00:07:59.980 --> 00:08:01.440
But seriously, you know, I don't like the two-party system.

00:08:01.440 --> 00:08:04.283
But seriously, you know, I don't like the two-party system.

00:08:04.283 --> 00:08:11.267
The thing is, none of that matters right now or, honestly, matters until Donald Trump and this entire mega-movement is no longer at the helm.

00:08:11.267 --> 00:08:23.817
One of these parties believes and upholds our institutions and democratic processes, and one idolizes and thinks a man who lies, bribes his way into office and undermines democratic institutions this country is built on is basically their savior.

00:08:30.060 --> 00:08:34.636
Maybe folks think this stance is too dramatic or we're being alarmist, but we don't think that, and many other nonpartisan organizations and experts in the field of democracy don't either.

00:08:34.636 --> 00:08:40.302
You're seeing political scientists explain how dangerous our current predicament is and how Trump could take us to a point of no return.

00:08:40.302 --> 00:08:46.955
We have no desire to be part of the theatrics you see in the likes of Marjorie Taylor Greene, and we're not out here trying to scare folks.

00:08:46.955 --> 00:08:48.599
But we are paying attention.

00:08:48.599 --> 00:08:53.871
We are reading from a variety of sources, we are looking at studies and analysis and it's not good guys.

00:08:53.871 --> 00:09:04.229
That's the gist here, and it's so, so important that folks understand that this is not an election between two candidates where we are debating the best policies on the economy or how best to handle international relations.

00:09:04.629 --> 00:09:22.366
This election, we are deciding if we find it acceptable to let the most powerful man in the world do whatever he wants Lie, cheat, incite an insurrection, spew and spread hatred, commit fraud, bribe porn stars to influence the outcome of elections, embolden extremists to act, tip our country into violence, et cetera, et cetera.

00:09:22.366 --> 00:09:23.028
I think you get the point.

00:09:23.028 --> 00:09:29.948
Or if we think that no one, and definitely not the most powerful man in the world, should be allowed to do these things or be above the law.

00:09:29.948 --> 00:09:34.765
We would absolutely not allow his behavior in our homes or our workplaces or our schools.

00:09:34.765 --> 00:09:36.912
Why would we allow it to lead our country?

00:09:37.759 --> 00:09:48.768
In this election, we're deciding if we'll be a country that will uphold those democratic institutions and practices, if we'll uphold our freedoms and our rights outlined in the Constitution, if we'll be a country that continues to separate religion from state.

00:09:48.768 --> 00:09:55.774
We're deciding if we'll be a country where Americans, no matter their religion, race, skin color or gender, do not have to be afraid.

00:09:55.774 --> 00:09:57.517
That's what's on the line this election.

00:09:57.517 --> 00:10:06.162
Content of the day.

00:10:06.162 --> 00:10:18.692
We will be blatant and obvious this election season that Donald Trump is so unbelievably beyond unfit to be the president of the United States, and we will be doing everything in our power to make sure that a man who does nothing but lies and has plans to consolidate power under him in the executive branch is defeated at the ballot box this November.

00:10:19.220 --> 00:10:19.822
Drops mic.

00:10:19.822 --> 00:10:23.591
If it didn't cause so much noise in the background, we would drop mic.

00:10:24.921 --> 00:10:26.707
But honestly I feel like I was just on a high horse there.

00:10:26.707 --> 00:10:28.043
Okay, stepping down.

00:10:28.043 --> 00:10:29.888
We're going to talk about the data and the facts.

00:10:29.888 --> 00:10:30.889
Guys, let's do it.

00:10:31.410 --> 00:10:31.952
It was lovely.

00:10:31.952 --> 00:10:38.812
I appreciated everything you just said, but, yes, data and facts, because you know, ash and I are huge data girls, if you know, you know.

00:10:38.812 --> 00:10:42.063
So we have to start with the state of violence in our country.

00:10:42.063 --> 00:10:49.235
First and foremost, donald Trump and MAGA Republicans are the problem when it comes to rhetoric that incites violence in this country.

00:10:49.235 --> 00:10:56.403
Let's just take a look at a few examples here.

00:10:56.423 --> 00:10:59.817
In 2016, and even more in 2020, trump supporters brought weapons to intimidate opponents and vote counters.

00:10:59.817 --> 00:11:06.793
After authorities apprehended a right-wearing extremist plot to abduct Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer, trump belittled the threat at a rally.

00:11:06.793 --> 00:11:09.749
He disparaged Whitmer as a political enemy.

00:11:09.749 --> 00:11:12.027
His supporters chanted lock her up.

00:11:12.027 --> 00:11:14.948
And Trump laughed and replied lock them all up.

00:11:14.948 --> 00:11:16.725
Ha ha, ha ha.

00:11:16.725 --> 00:11:27.083
At an event in California back in October of 2023, shortly after Nancy Pelosi's husband was a victim of political violence, aka was attacked with a hammer.

00:11:27.083 --> 00:11:42.851
Trump says in a speech together we will take on the ultra left-wing liars, losers, creepers, perverts and freaks who are devouring the future of this state like a swarm of locusts his biggest supporters in government are no better, and he endorses these people and he emboldens them.

00:11:43.400 --> 00:11:48.293
Let's just look at one example here, and we we're going to go with GOP representative Marjorie Taylor Greene.

00:11:48.293 --> 00:11:54.990
She repeatedly expressed support for assassinating powerful Democrats In 2018 on Facebook.

00:11:54.990 --> 00:11:58.985
A supporter wrote on one of her posts in quotes here now do we get to hang them?

00:11:58.985 --> 00:12:04.047
Question mark question mark meaning H and O question mark question mark question question mark.

00:12:04.047 --> 00:12:08.389
That person was referring to obama and former secretary of state hillary clinton for h and o.

00:12:08.389 --> 00:12:16.260
Just to make sense of this, marjorie taylor green responded with in quotes here the stage is being set, players are being put in place.

00:12:16.260 --> 00:12:17.383
We must be patient.

00:12:17.383 --> 00:12:20.868
This must be done perfectly or liberal judges would let them off.

00:12:21.609 --> 00:12:32.408
End quote I mean like I just that is someone who is in one of the highest elected federal congress.

00:12:32.828 --> 00:12:35.395
Yeah, yes, and then in 2019.

00:12:35.395 --> 00:12:37.923
Let's just, let's keep the ball rolling in 2019.

00:12:37.923 --> 00:12:43.443
She liked a facebook comment suggesting nancy pelosi get a, in quote pure bullet to the head.

00:12:44.144 --> 00:12:45.708
So lovely, isn't?

00:12:45.769 --> 00:12:47.953
it't it what those GOP people say.

00:12:49.020 --> 00:12:51.927
I can't even go on because my jaw won't stop dropping.

00:12:51.927 --> 00:12:59.152
And this doesn't even scratch the surface of things MAGA leaders are out there saying, or the impact that it actually has.

00:12:59.152 --> 00:13:09.368
Abc published a finding in 2020 where they could directly tie 54 cases of violence, threats or assaults back to the then-President, trump being the motivator behind them.

00:13:09.368 --> 00:13:20.476
Reviewing police reports and court records, abc News found that in at least 12 cases, perpetrators hailed Trump in the midst of immediate aftermath of physically assaulting innocent victims.

00:13:20.476 --> 00:13:28.004
In another 18 cases, perpetrators cheered or defended Trump while taunting or threatening others.

00:13:28.004 --> 00:13:33.465
And in another 10 cases, trump and his rhetoric were cited in court to explain defendants' violent or threatening behavior.

00:13:34.527 --> 00:13:39.605
And this report was from 2020, so it doesn't even touch anything that has happened since then.

00:13:40.245 --> 00:13:43.961
And let me just be clear, a lot has happened since then.

00:13:44.904 --> 00:13:49.139
Trump and MAGA Republicans are the problem here when it comes to rhetoric that incites violence.

00:13:49.139 --> 00:13:57.274
We can't let the media or anyone spin this narrative now that it's both sides just because Trump was impacted by the same violence he regularly incites.

00:13:57.274 --> 00:13:59.004
Both sides are not the same.

00:13:59.004 --> 00:14:06.068
Let's just compare the responses to the political violence events of Nancy Pelosi's husband and to the assassination attempt on Trump.

00:14:06.068 --> 00:14:20.010
Just to kind of prove our point way more here, when a crazy man with a hammer almost killed the husband of then House Speaker, nancy Pelosi, donald Trump jeered and mocked in a speech where supporters in the crowd laughed and we do have video of this.

00:14:20.010 --> 00:14:24.312
I unfortunately watched it prepping for this episode and it is just as appalling as it sounds.

00:14:24.312 --> 00:14:26.982
I unfortunately watched it prepping for this episode and it is just as appalling as it sounds.

00:14:26.982 --> 00:14:28.484
Link is in the show notes if you really want to see it.

00:14:28.484 --> 00:14:30.405
Then on Truth Social he also wrote this.

00:14:30.927 --> 00:14:43.360
I purposely didn't comment on Nancy Pelosi's very weird story concerning her husband, but now I can because she said something about me with glee that was really quite vicious and he has it in quotes here of what she said.

00:14:43.360 --> 00:14:49.287
And he said I saw a scared puppy, she said as she watched me on television, like millions of others that didn't see that I wasn't scared.

00:14:49.287 --> 00:14:51.548
Nevertheless, how mean a thing to say.

00:14:51.548 --> 00:14:55.832
She is a wicked witch whose husband's journey from hell starts and finishes with her.

00:14:55.832 --> 00:14:59.636
She is sick and a demented psycho who will someday live in hell.

00:15:04.399 --> 00:15:08.419
This is after this man was brutally beaten with a hammer in the head and almost killed Then on top of that.

00:15:08.419 --> 00:15:09.600
So that's Donald Trump's response.

00:15:09.600 --> 00:15:19.846
Donald Jr, his son, retweeted a photo of a Paul Pelosi Halloween costume in quotes here, showing a picture of underwear and a hammer, because, for those that don't know, he was in his underwear when he was attacked.

00:15:19.846 --> 00:15:23.028
So very sensitive humans.

00:15:23.028 --> 00:15:23.849
Here we have right.

00:15:23.849 --> 00:15:37.816
Someone was brutally attacked and this is the response, and several GOP members, instead of reaching out or offering condolences, like everyone has done since the attempted assassination of former President Trump, these are the kinds of things they're saying, and GOP members started conspiracy theories around the attack.

00:15:38.797 --> 00:15:39.897
Real impasse here.

00:15:39.897 --> 00:15:42.422
Yeah, yeah, yes.

00:15:42.422 --> 00:15:49.393
So, as Ashley mentioned, there has been some responses after the attempted assassination of Donald Trump and we're going to dive into those here.

00:15:49.393 --> 00:16:02.022
So we'll start with Nancy Pelosi, because it seems quite fitting she wrote in quotes here as one whose family has been the victim of political violence, I know firsthand that political violence of any kind has no place in our society.

00:16:02.022 --> 00:16:04.688
I thank God that former President Trump is safe.

00:16:04.688 --> 00:16:11.703
As we learn more details about this horrifying incident, let us pray that all those in attendance at the former president's rally today are unharmed.

00:16:11.703 --> 00:16:13.087
That was Nancy.

00:16:13.087 --> 00:16:15.192
Now President Biden wrote in quotes.

00:16:15.192 --> 00:16:17.826
I'm grateful to hear that he's safe and doing well.

00:16:17.826 --> 00:16:23.062
I'm praying for him and his family and for all of those who are at the rally as we await further information.

00:16:23.062 --> 00:16:51.057
Jill and I are grateful to the next day from the Oval Office, and he said in that address again quotes here we stand for an america not of extremism and fury, but of decency and grace I mean, can we see the difference?

00:16:51.157 --> 00:16:54.705
I hope it's very obvious, but, um, I'll know.

00:16:54.705 --> 00:17:05.808
Yeah, so just to drive the point home here, and apparently I really had marjorie taylor green at the top of my mind when I was looking for people who said bad things, but I know she does, so I probably did.

00:17:05.808 --> 00:17:07.872
It's not hard to find.

00:17:07.872 --> 00:17:09.595
Yeah, here is her response.

00:17:09.595 --> 00:17:18.309
And this is the response to after Donald Trump's assassination attempt, where most people are calling for unity and lessening rhetoric and all that kind of good stuff.

00:17:18.309 --> 00:17:19.820
Here is what she wrote in quotes.

00:17:19.820 --> 00:17:23.984
Here we are in a battle between good and evil Good and evil in caps, by the way.

00:17:23.984 --> 00:17:30.872
The Democrats are the party of pedophiles murdering the innocent, unborn violence and bloody, meaningless, endless wars.

00:17:30.872 --> 00:17:35.916
They want to lock up their political opponents and terrorize innocent Americans who would tell the truth about it.

00:17:35.916 --> 00:17:40.601
The Democrat?

00:17:40.621 --> 00:17:42.185
Party is flat-out evil and yesterday they tried to murder President Trump.

00:17:42.185 --> 00:17:51.101
And just a side note here there is no evidence at all that any Democrat was involved or that even this man who attempted the assassination was moved or motivated by Democrats.

00:17:51.101 --> 00:17:55.112
The person who attempted the assassination was a registered Republican.

00:17:55.112 --> 00:18:05.536
There's also evidence that he donated $15 to ActBlue, the Democratic fundraising apparatus, on January 20th 2021, the date of President Joe Biden's inauguration.

00:18:05.536 --> 00:18:16.912
The donation was earmarked for the Progressive Turnout Project, but this organization says that this was the only donation from him and he's been unsubscribed from their list for over two years now.

00:18:17.240 --> 00:18:18.663
Good point, sarah, really good point.

00:18:18.663 --> 00:18:26.647
So back to our main point of this section here is that MAGA messaging Trump and those he endorses are the problem here.

00:18:26.647 --> 00:18:28.089
When it comes to inciting violence.

00:18:28.089 --> 00:18:33.489
In the current state we are in in our country, both sides are not the same and we have to stop pretending like they are.

00:18:33.921 --> 00:18:41.074
So the violence alone should honestly be enough, in our opinion, to end conversations about why Trump and MAGA Republicans are unfit.

00:18:41.074 --> 00:18:43.487
Like that's it, folks.

00:18:43.487 --> 00:18:49.306
He's a man who spews hatred and has incited the worst in so many over the past almost decade.

00:18:49.306 --> 00:18:49.847
Honestly.

00:18:49.847 --> 00:19:07.891
But if that's not enough and we know for some folks it isn't, somehow but we want to talk about one of the arguments we've either heard or seen out there from people, and that is it wasn't that bad the first time, meaning it wasn't that bad the first time president or former President Donald Trump was in office.

00:19:07.891 --> 00:19:12.550
First of all, we still don't fully understand the damage he did, as it's still playing out.

00:19:12.660 --> 00:19:21.701
But let's talk about the damage we do know about, and we're going to start with the entire fake news world we live in now, which is so dangerous, where there are some kindling here.

00:19:21.701 --> 00:19:28.035
Prior to Trump entering the scene, he added gasoline and then lit the match when he started his campaign back in 2015.

00:19:28.035 --> 00:19:41.291
Norman Ornstein, a scholar at the conservative American Enterprise Institute back in 2015, said there were a couple of forces at play for years before Trump entered politics that has enabled him to do this.

00:19:41.291 --> 00:19:51.169
Those forces were the fact that people were desensitized to inflammatory rhetoric, the assault on science and expertise and the increasing reliance on partisan media.

00:19:51.169 --> 00:20:00.349
Add the ability for conspiracy theories and disinformation to spread on social media and we have the lack for a better word here, the shitshow we are in now.

00:20:00.852 --> 00:20:01.921
We do so.

00:20:01.921 --> 00:20:16.028
In 2016, oxford Dictionary selected the word post-truth as its word of the year and defined it as the state of affairs when, in quotes here, objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief.

00:20:16.028 --> 00:20:18.303
And I think that kind of sums up the 2016 election.

00:20:18.303 --> 00:20:22.761
Anyway, this is exactly the world we started living in back then and continue to live in now.

00:20:22.761 --> 00:20:35.992
Politifact, which is a non-profit organization that credibly fact-checks politicians on both sides of the aisle, named Fake News their Lie of 2016, and said in quotes here fake news is the boldest sign of a post-truth society.

00:20:35.992 --> 00:20:41.642
When we can't agree on basic facts, or even that there are such things as facts, how do we even talk to each other?

00:20:41.642 --> 00:20:47.473
And this quote exactly sums up the point we are trying to make here the objective truth seems to no longer matter.

00:20:47.473 --> 00:20:53.948
Let's just take a super basic example that really shouldn't have anything to do with politics, to be honest, and that's the weather.

00:20:53.948 --> 00:20:57.547
Do we all remember sharpie gate in 2019?

00:20:57.909 --> 00:21:04.630
well, if you don't, don't worry, we'll remind you so we can walk through this example of how trump and team refuse to live in a land of reality.

00:21:04.630 --> 00:21:14.509
Trump tweeted in 2019 that Alabama was one of the states at greater risk for Hurricane Dorian than had been initially forecasted.

00:21:14.509 --> 00:21:19.971
This hurricane was on track to hit the east coast of Florida, so not the Gulf where Alabama is located.

00:21:19.971 --> 00:21:27.712
The Federal Weather Office in Birmingham then tweeted that actually, alabama would be unaffected by the storm, unlike what the president had said.

00:21:27.712 --> 00:21:41.913
Trump, having to be right and unwilling to accept reality, then went on basically a campaign to assure folks that Alabama was at risk, and this effort included eventually showcasing a hurricane map that was crudely altered with a Sharpie.

00:21:41.913 --> 00:21:45.808
The Sharpie was used to include Alabama in the track of the hurricane.

00:21:46.390 --> 00:21:47.973
Just Google it, folks, if you want to see the drawing.

00:21:47.973 --> 00:21:48.936
It's pretty pathetic.

00:21:48.936 --> 00:21:53.228
Maybe you or someone you know would be like whatever everyone knows.

00:21:53.228 --> 00:21:53.828
That's not real.

00:21:53.828 --> 00:21:55.011
Well, here's the issue.

00:21:55.011 --> 00:21:56.625
First of all, folks don't.

00:21:56.625 --> 00:22:01.684
Some people think the media and everything about it is made up and they only believe what this man now says.

00:22:02.641 --> 00:22:11.613
Second, and maybe the bigger issue here is that behind the scenes, the White House jumped into action to try to pressure federal weather experts into saying Trump was right and they were wrong.

00:22:11.613 --> 00:22:13.586
And this is the dangerous part.

00:22:13.586 --> 00:22:16.304
He's not a lone man spewing his lies.

00:22:16.304 --> 00:22:25.882
He was surrounded then by a bunch of yes, people, an entire team of people in powerful positions who will do what they can to ensure his false narratives and lies are sold to as many people as possible.

00:22:25.882 --> 00:22:28.307
And if people didn't do that, he fired them.

00:22:28.307 --> 00:22:30.330
So back to the question.

00:22:30.330 --> 00:22:39.394
If we can't even agree on the path of a hurricane which experts came together and published no one else was disputing this hurricane path how do we talk to each other?

00:22:39.394 --> 00:22:43.131
How do we have meaningful conversations about real issues impacting America?

00:22:43.131 --> 00:22:46.549
We just can't, and Trump and team have created this situation for us.

00:22:47.580 --> 00:22:52.471
I do want to give props to whoever coined the term Sharpie, sharpie.

00:22:52.830 --> 00:22:53.873
I know so solid.

00:22:53.873 --> 00:23:00.846
I know I saw it in an article, it's in the sources somewhere, but yeah, I'm not sure where it first started, but it is pretty solid.

00:23:01.467 --> 00:23:04.472
Oh my gosh, that's incredible, oh man.

00:23:04.859 --> 00:23:14.442
Ok, so let's move on to the second thing we're going to talk about today in regards to the damage that he's already done, and this is going to be the damage he has done to our democratic processes.

00:23:14.843 --> 00:23:24.614
The big news world that he has created, that we just talked about, has made it possible to also undermine democracy, primarily through false claims on election fraud Before the 2016 election.

00:23:24.614 --> 00:23:32.343
So almost a decade ago which is crazy to say he started making claims that widespread voter fraud is happening in the United States.

00:23:32.343 --> 00:23:36.049
This is completely untrue and we'll share the research on this later.

00:23:36.049 --> 00:23:42.426
To prove this point, and even at the time, both Democratic and Republican election officials were telling folks it was not true.

00:23:42.426 --> 00:23:49.006
Trump claimed this fraud during the 2016 election when he was down in the polls, and he said it even after he won too.

00:23:49.006 --> 00:23:56.503
His ultimate goal Get folks to not believe election results, hence undermining one of our most critical components of our democracy.

00:23:56.503 --> 00:24:06.727
And we could not go without saying that this rhetoric he started back then set him up for the exact scenario we saw in 2020, where he would claim the election results were false and tried to stay in power.

00:24:07.288 --> 00:24:35.570
We'll talk so much about this more later, but it's so hugely important to note here as we personally believe it's in the top five as one of the most damaging things that he's done, and I mean that's saying something, because this man's list of bad things he's done is long long, long, and speaking of long, we could honestly go on and on about the different ways he has caused damage, but we have to keep this episode to a reasonable length, so we are only going to touch on one more thing here, and that is the damage he has done to our judicial branch.

00:24:35.570 --> 00:24:51.884
As I think most people know, he appointed three Supreme Court justices while in office, which has led to our current Supreme Court makeup, which is made up of six conservative and three liberal justices, and this court has been busy, undoing decades of precedent and helping slowly erode some components of our democracy.

00:24:51.884 --> 00:24:59.844
We'll talk through a few examples here in a minute, but first we would be remiss to not say that Trump should have really only been able to appoint two justices while he was in office.

00:25:00.625 --> 00:25:03.653
So let's take a quick trip back to 2016.

00:25:03.653 --> 00:25:13.025
The GOP majority in the Senate in 2016 kept a Supreme Court seat open for a year and would not enable Obama to fill it, because they claimed it was an election year.

00:25:13.025 --> 00:25:15.028
In February of 2016,.

00:25:15.028 --> 00:25:16.390
Obama to fill it because they claimed it was an election year.

00:25:16.390 --> 00:25:17.310
In February of 2016,.

00:25:17.310 --> 00:25:20.255
Conservative legal giant Justice Antonin Scalia died, leaving a space on the Supreme Court.

00:25:20.255 --> 00:25:28.669
The process is relatively straightforward the sitting president nominates a qualified candidate and then the Senate votes to confirm with a simple majority.

00:25:28.689 --> 00:25:34.692
Just hours after Scalia's death, republican Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell announced that he would block any such move.

00:25:34.692 --> 00:25:39.182
He said the American people should have a voice in the selection of their next Supreme Court justice.

00:25:39.182 --> 00:25:42.852
Therefore, this vacancy should not be filled until we have a new president.

00:25:42.852 --> 00:25:46.231
Senate Republicans joined with him in blocking the appointment.

00:25:46.231 --> 00:25:49.723
It was an unprecedented decision that sparked a large political battle.

00:25:49.723 --> 00:25:57.311
In the end, mitch McConnell got his way and Merrick Garland, the moderate candidate nominated by Barack Obama, did not take a seat on the court.

00:25:57.311 --> 00:26:02.172
Instead, donald Trump nominated and confirmed Neil Gorsuch after he was elected.

00:26:02.580 --> 00:26:05.691
Let's fast forward four years later and the tables were turned.

00:26:05.691 --> 00:26:12.493
Ruth Bader Ginsburg died just six weeks before the 2020 presidential election, leaving a space on the Supreme Court to be filled.

00:26:12.493 --> 00:26:15.489
So what did the GOPp controlled senate do this time?

00:26:15.489 --> 00:26:19.852
They rushed through an appointment for donald trump to ensure amy coney barrett filled the vacancy.

00:26:19.852 --> 00:26:22.027
I mean the hypocrisy.

00:26:22.027 --> 00:26:23.633
Like this is I, you know.

00:26:23.633 --> 00:26:29.228
I really just put this in this episode to prove this point of like these people don't play fair anymore.

00:26:29.228 --> 00:26:30.971
There, there's no decorum.

00:26:30.971 --> 00:26:31.941
There's you know what I mean?

00:26:31.941 --> 00:26:32.903
Like it's just.

00:26:32.903 --> 00:26:34.445
This is how this is operating now.

00:26:35.188 --> 00:26:41.688
So, just to ensure we understand how really slimy this was, here's a direct quote from Lindsey Graham, who's a Republican Senator from South Carolina.

00:26:41.688 --> 00:26:53.506
In October of 2018, so in the middle of Trump's term he, in quotes here, said I'll tell you this if an opening comes in President Trump's term and the primary process has started, we will wait until the next election.

00:26:53.506 --> 00:26:58.294
So, with that history in mind, let's talk about what this has meant to our country.

00:26:58.294 --> 00:26:58.554
Really.

00:26:58.554 --> 00:27:05.528
The Supreme Court has rolled back decades of precedent, and this precedent hasn't been set by just liberal judges.

00:27:05.528 --> 00:27:13.952
This is precedent from Supreme Courts that have been mostly conservative leaning as our courts really, especially our Supreme Court, has been most of our recent history.

00:27:13.952 --> 00:27:20.561
So this is precedent set by other conservative justices over the last century that basically this new court has gone and upended.

00:27:20.903 --> 00:27:36.270
I hate that we have to do this, but we're going to go through some of their most notable rulings, and the first one here will come to no surprise to anyone the Dobbs decision in 2022, which was Dobbs v Jackson Women's Health Organization.

00:27:36.270 --> 00:27:44.186
This is a landmark decision of the US Supreme Court, in which the court held that the Constitution of the United States does not confer a right to abortion.

00:27:44.186 --> 00:27:57.663
The court's decision overruled both Roe v Wade from 1973 and Planned Parenthood v Casey from 1992, returning to individual states the power to regulate any aspect of abortion not protected by federal law.

00:27:57.663 --> 00:28:12.240
To be fair on this ruling, many legal scholars over the years have said that abortion was protected on very shaky legal grounds in the Roe ruling, but this ruling did go against past legal precedent and obviously greatly endangers women's lives and health all over the country.

00:28:12.761 --> 00:28:15.288
We're just going to move on from that, because it's one of our most sore subjects.

00:28:15.288 --> 00:28:21.835
So the second one we have to talk about is Trump v the United States, which just happened here in 2024, very, very recently.

00:28:21.835 --> 00:28:26.074
This is the decision that gives presidents immunity from criminal prosecution.

00:28:26.074 --> 00:28:32.681
The court ruled that the president has absolute immunity for acts they commit as president within their core constitutional purview.

00:28:32.681 --> 00:28:42.009
At least presumptive immunity for official acts within the outer perimeter of his official responsibility should be his or hers anyway, and no immunity for unofficial acts.

00:28:42.009 --> 00:28:43.615
So what is an official act?

00:28:43.615 --> 00:28:50.983
Well, that's a great question, but they basically made it impossible for non-official acts to be tried anyway, so I'm not sure the definition really matters.

00:28:50.983 --> 00:28:52.627
Here's an example of why that is.

00:28:53.108 --> 00:28:56.288
Let's look at Trump's attempt to overthrow the election results of 2020.

00:28:56.288 --> 00:29:00.481
Communicating with the attorney general as president is clearly an official act.

00:29:00.481 --> 00:29:11.247
Trump sought to have his acting attorney general send a letter to the states to discuss investigating alleged election fraud and, after the acting attorney general refused, repeatedly threatened to replace him.

00:29:11.247 --> 00:29:19.413
Trump is absolutely immune from prosecution involving discussions with Justice Department officials, and this evidence cannot even be used to prosecute him.

00:29:19.413 --> 00:29:22.948
So even if they decide something he did was not an official act.

00:29:22.948 --> 00:29:31.325
They can't use any of this evidence against him because he was talking to someone which he is covered under, basically being the official act of a president.

00:29:31.325 --> 00:29:46.143
It's extremely dangerous and opens the door to a president really having no consequences down the road for whatever action they want to take, and I've read a lot on this ruling and I have not seen a single legal scholar come out and say that it was really in any way justified.

00:29:46.644 --> 00:29:50.171
Oh my, this just also makes me want to vomit.

00:29:51.071 --> 00:29:53.961
And the list goes on, but again, we only have so much time here.

00:29:53.961 --> 00:30:07.797
So lastly, and maybe one of the most broadly impactful to everyday life, is the overturning of the Chevron deference doctrine in the Loper Bright Enterprises v Raimondo, also decided just recently here in 2024.

00:30:07.797 --> 00:30:15.614
The Chevron deference, set in 1984, gave federal agencies wide powers to interpret laws and decide the best ways to apply them.

00:30:15.614 --> 00:30:23.891
The idea was that if Congress passes a law where something is unclear or there is a gap, it is up to an agency to fill in the gap.

00:30:23.891 --> 00:30:36.842
This gave agencies in the federal government, such as the Environmental Protection Agency, the freedom to create and implement rules without fear of legal battles In areas like workplace safety, financial markets and the environment.

00:30:37.323 --> 00:30:45.556
Courts and, by extension, businesses contemplating legal challenges to regulations had to yield to agencies' interpretations of laws.

00:30:45.556 --> 00:30:57.702
When the court ended this deference in this 2024 ruling, the conservative majority slashed and severely weakened the powers of agencies, including the EPA, the FDA, labor agencies, etc.

00:30:57.702 --> 00:31:11.607
Advocacy groups argue it will be a setback for clean water, public health, fair lending, worker safety and other areas where people rely on federal agencies who are made up of experts like doctors and scientists to set laws and regulations.

00:31:11.607 --> 00:31:25.430
It's also viewed as a huge power grab for the courts, because now it will be judges making decisions and they do not have the expertise necessarily to decide things like how much nitrogen may be discharged by a wastewater treatment plant.

00:31:25.819 --> 00:31:27.487
So how are we feeling about that?

00:31:27.487 --> 00:31:29.548
It wasn't that bad the first time argument.

00:31:30.079 --> 00:31:33.666
Super, super great, Ha ha ha ha ha ha.

00:31:34.099 --> 00:31:38.243
Well, maybe if you're like us, you think it's a bit weak, but like a bad infomercial.

00:31:38.243 --> 00:31:40.410
Don't worry, folks, we're not done yet.

00:31:40.410 --> 00:31:41.271
We have more.

00:31:41.271 --> 00:31:51.553
So we've talked about some of the major ways he has already done damage to our country and now let's talk about why he is set up to do even more basically round two, if he gets a chance.

00:31:58.039 --> 00:31:59.324
His first time around, he wasn't expecting to win.

00:31:59.324 --> 00:32:03.258
I don't have a source linked in the show notes on this, but I've read several articles from Republican leaders and policy people and stuff that help with this.

00:32:03.258 --> 00:32:04.221
No one was expecting him to win.

00:32:04.221 --> 00:32:06.307
He was down in the polls, all this kind of stuff.

00:32:06.307 --> 00:32:08.402
So he wasn't expecting to win the first round.

00:32:08.402 --> 00:32:09.984
Like I said, he was down in the polls.

00:32:09.984 --> 00:32:12.648
That's why he was spewing election fraud rhetoric.

00:32:12.648 --> 00:32:18.730
The point is he didn't think he would win, so he didn't have a plan on what to do once he got into the Oval.

00:32:18.730 --> 00:32:23.692
He also is not a career politician and did not have really any political experience.

00:32:23.692 --> 00:32:28.808
He had no experience in regards to how government works, so he really didn't know what he was doing the first time around.

00:32:29.180 --> 00:32:32.250
Well guys, he knows better now and he is expecting to win this time.

00:32:32.250 --> 00:32:52.444
There's an entire plan around how to get all the things he wants done and, yes, we are talking about Project 2025, and we will be doing episodes on this in the future, so we're not going to go into a ton of detail today, but we'll just say this for now Project 2025 is a 900-something page document on how he can consolidate power in the executive branch and what he will do with all that power once he has it.

00:32:52.444 --> 00:32:56.972
Like I said, we'll have episodes on it soon, but it's not some conspiracy theory or far-fetched thing.

00:32:56.972 --> 00:32:57.714
That cannot happen.

00:32:57.714 --> 00:33:07.308
Scholars, doctors, policymakers, smart and extremely conservative people wrote this playbook and it gives a step-by-step for Trump to gain incredible power if he gets back in office.

00:33:07.308 --> 00:33:18.987
All this to say, he is much more prepared this time to get the things he wants done than he was the first time and he knows how to remove people who are going to be in his way.

00:33:18.932 --> 00:33:22.755
The second reason he is better set up to cause more damage than round one is because of rulings put out over the past several years by the Supreme Court.

00:33:22.755 --> 00:33:32.712
We already touched on a few, but the major one we'll call out here is the 2024 ruling in Trump v United States, which is the presidential immunity case that we again discussed in detail.

00:33:32.712 --> 00:33:46.571
Another important call out here around the judicial branch is that Trump appointed more than 200 judges to the federal bench, including nearly as many powerful federal appeal court judges, in four years as Barack Obama appointed in eight.

00:33:46.571 --> 00:33:56.782
He worked closely with Majority Leader Mitch McConnell and other Senate Republicans to reshape the federal judiciary, particularly the appeals courts, for decades to come.

00:33:57.325 --> 00:34:03.626
Federal judges have lifetime tenure and typically remain on the bench long after the presidents who nominated them have left office.

00:34:03.626 --> 00:34:07.103
We've already seen rulings from some of these judges in favor of Trump.

00:34:07.103 --> 00:34:23.012
For example, just recently, one of the judges who was appointed by him and was overseeing Trump's federal case for allegedly taking and concealing classified documents after leaving office, decided to rule against decades of established law and precedent to just toss the case out of court.

00:34:23.012 --> 00:34:26.791
His overhaul of the federal judiciary should concern everyone.

00:34:26.791 --> 00:34:32.391
We have already seen that some of his appointees are unwilling to use the courts as they should to hold him accountable.

00:34:32.391 --> 00:34:33.172
Womp, womp.

00:34:33.552 --> 00:34:34.822
All right, womp, womp.

00:34:34.822 --> 00:34:35.324
All right, womp, womp.

00:34:35.324 --> 00:34:36.548
Oh, I know, okay.

00:34:36.548 --> 00:34:45.431
So we're going to move into, kind of our last main section here today and that's around really, democracy and the fact that our country is on the backslide.

00:34:45.431 --> 00:34:48.969
So you know, this is something we've been alluding to over and over.

00:34:48.969 --> 00:34:55.552
We definitely alluded to it a lot in our introductions today, but democracies fall or slide towards autocracy all the time.

00:34:55.552 --> 00:35:00.096
It is our job as citizens to protect our democracy if we want to keep it.

00:35:00.376 --> 00:35:09.148
I was talking to a family member about the upcoming election and they literally said something to me like this I trust the Constitution to keep Trump in check if he gains power again.

00:35:09.148 --> 00:35:15.110
And I'm crap you, not my eyeballs, I feel like maybe were popping out of my head, my jaw was hitting the floor.

00:35:15.110 --> 00:35:16.280
I was just.

00:35:16.280 --> 00:35:25.168
I didn't actually even respond well in the moment because I was just so shocked by this statement, but I want to say, excuse me, sir, this is like a 250-year-old document.

00:35:25.168 --> 00:35:30.829
Our country has drastically changed and that constitution has been altered 27 times.

00:35:30.829 --> 00:35:37.242
As of 2021, the United States is no longer even considered a full democracy and is now considered a flawed democracy.

00:35:37.242 --> 00:35:42.541
So please tell me how this document is going to keep our democracy.

00:35:42.541 --> 00:35:49.005
It just I just seems so incredible to me that that was the statement that came out of their mouth, so just let me know, let me know.

00:35:49.286 --> 00:35:53.103
Yeah, I would love to see the love, to see your backing of that.

00:35:53.103 --> 00:35:55.771
Okay, so it may seem obvious, but we have to say it.

00:35:55.771 --> 00:35:58.847
Democracy only works if the people make it work.

00:35:58.847 --> 00:36:06.710
We must vote, we have to be informed, we have to advocate and fight for what we care about and we must be the ones to defend that democracy and our freedoms.

00:36:06.710 --> 00:36:10.590
We do not get to sit back and be like the Constitution will just do its thing.

00:36:10.590 --> 00:36:13.264
I mean, I just still get worked up about that statement.

00:36:13.264 --> 00:36:16.050
I think that actually might be the most in this whole episode.

00:36:16.050 --> 00:36:17.472
That might be the thing that worked me up the most.

00:36:18.802 --> 00:36:20.005
I don't blame you at all.

00:36:20.005 --> 00:36:22.150
So, ash, we're going to let you take a breath here.

00:36:22.150 --> 00:36:24.382
But back to our audience.

00:36:24.382 --> 00:36:37.032
If you need some help convincing someone that we have to protect our democracy, especially if that someone is your Republican parents or grandparents use this quote from one of their favorite Republican presidents, ronald Reagan, in quotes here.

00:36:37.032 --> 00:36:41.489
Freedom is a fragile thing and is never more than one generation away from extinction.

00:36:41.489 --> 00:36:44.088
It is not ours by way of inheritance.

00:36:44.088 --> 00:36:47.610
It must be fought for and defended constantly by each generation.

00:36:47.610 --> 00:36:57.528
And if that quote isn't enough, we're going to share some data and research that proves this exact point and explains the current state of our democracy and a little bit about how we got here.

00:36:57.528 --> 00:37:07.030
Hint, hint, our democracy is backsliding, aka moving away from democracy, like Ash said, and a ton of the why ties back to Trump and the MAGA movement.

00:37:07.601 --> 00:37:11.552
So, like we said before, democracies slide towards autocracy all the time.

00:37:11.552 --> 00:37:17.349
Let's take a moment to define autocracy, just so everyone understands what we are talking about here for the next couple minutes.

00:37:17.349 --> 00:37:21.485
Autocracy is the authority or rule of an autocrat, which I know is not super helpful.

00:37:21.485 --> 00:37:23.371
So let's talk about what an autocrat is.

00:37:23.371 --> 00:37:32.865
Well, it's defined as a person such as a monarch or someone else ruling with unlimited authority, or one who has undisputed influence or power.

00:37:33.065 --> 00:37:45.012
Many people think when democracies fall, there are tanks rolling through the streets, troops marching through cities, coups overthrowing governments and, basically, democracy going out with a bang or a series of bangs.

00:37:45.012 --> 00:37:46.940
These kinds of takeovers do happen, but more times than not, democracies tend to erode.

00:37:46.940 --> 00:37:49.125
Before collapsing, they backslide first.

00:37:49.125 --> 00:37:58.231
The most recent examples of established democracies that have become autocracies have all happened more gradually, incrementally building to the point where little of the old system remains.

00:37:58.231 --> 00:38:05.911
We aren't going into the details today on this, but if you want to look into some of these examples, you could look at countries like Brazil, poland, turkey or India.

00:38:05.911 --> 00:38:10.768
These are all nations that have seen a significant backsliding in their democracy since 2000.

00:38:11.351 --> 00:38:12.596
So back to our point here.

00:38:12.596 --> 00:38:18.367
The sharpest turns toward autocracy have frequently coincided with the election of extreme conservative leaders.

00:38:18.367 --> 00:38:25.034
We really just want to quote this whole article, because it's basically exactly what we're seeing play out with Trump.

00:38:25.034 --> 00:38:39.469
Sebastian Hellmeyer, one of the researchers who examined episodes of democracy's backsliding, said in quotes here the actors that promote autocratization are usually the chief executives, and they can have large parliamentary majorities.

00:38:39.469 --> 00:38:43.541
End quote Chief executive, aka in our government, that is the president.

00:38:43.541 --> 00:38:45.628
He goes on to say quotes.

00:38:45.628 --> 00:38:51.509
In the end it's kind of a death by a million cuts, with a lot of similar changes that are difficult to stop until it's too late.

00:38:51.509 --> 00:39:11.472
End quote Again sound familiar Rights being attacked around the country, voting access being restricted, the president being above the law, the appointment of so many judges that have proven they are more concerned with carrying forward conservative ideals than justice, the SCOTUS making power grabs in their recent ruling through the Chevron case, et cetera.

00:39:11.472 --> 00:39:12.498
I'm out of breath, man.

00:39:13.121 --> 00:39:13.561
I know right.

00:39:13.561 --> 00:39:18.072
So, if we didn't make it abundantly clear, we are considered a backsliding democracy.

00:39:18.072 --> 00:39:24.264
The 2021 edition of the Global State of Democracy Report marked the first appearance of the United States on that list.

00:39:24.264 --> 00:39:31.190
This backsliding episode began at least in 2019, with signals as early as 2016 and origins possibly before that.

00:39:31.190 --> 00:39:35.282
So our democracy is backsliding, and that is definitely not a good place to be.

00:39:35.282 --> 00:39:51.724
Of the 81 democracies that have went through some type of backsliding since 1900, as of today, only seven of those democracies remain democracies Only seven, that's 8.6% of democracies that have went through some form of backsliding still being democracies today.

00:39:51.724 --> 00:40:00.844
12 of those remain in crisis and 62 have turned to autocracies Not to give you the most depressing news ever, but there's the data for you Y'all.

00:40:00.885 --> 00:40:02.708
I'm scared, okay.

00:40:02.708 --> 00:40:05.501
So what puts us in the category of backsliding?

00:40:05.501 --> 00:40:12.443
A few things, but a report from Brookings Institute published in September of 2023 named two main factors.

00:40:12.443 --> 00:40:16.570
Those are election manipulation and executive overreach.

00:40:16.570 --> 00:40:28.768
On election manipulation, the report goes on to state most obviously, after the 2020 election, the sitting president, despite admitting privately that he had lost, attempted to subvert the results and remain in office.

00:40:28.768 --> 00:40:42.628
Gop-led state legislators since 2010 have also instituted laws intended to reduce voters' access to the ballot, politicize election administration and foreclose electoral competition via extreme gerrymandering.

00:40:42.889 --> 00:40:48.456
So, going off of that GOP activity, that started happening, you know, back in 2010,.

00:40:48.456 --> 00:40:56.909
We then had Donald Trump come along and cause huge unjustified mistrust in our election system and processes and he emboldened those GOP-led state legislatures even more.

00:40:56.909 --> 00:41:02.396
Until recently, election administration was nonpartisan, but in many states it has now become a partisan issue.

00:41:02.396 --> 00:41:10.106
Since 2020, state legislatures have passed dozens of laws to increase partisan control over election administration and vote counting procedures.

00:41:10.106 --> 00:41:17.800
Politicization also continues at the local level, with many veteran election administrators retiring and, in some cases, being replaced with election deniers.

00:41:17.800 --> 00:41:18.402
This is all in response to the election denial Trump and, in some cases, being replaced with election deniers.

00:41:18.619 --> 00:41:23.672
This is all in response to the election denial Trump and Magas have spewed for four years now.

00:41:23.672 --> 00:41:32.572
They went to court several times some were courts with Trump-appointed judges and none of the election or voter fraud cases ever stuck because they have no evidence.

00:41:32.572 --> 00:41:35.369
Our elections are secure and free and fair.

00:41:35.369 --> 00:41:50.657
In fact, the Brennan Center's report the Truth About Voter Fraud conclusively demonstrated that most allegations of fraud turn out to be baseless and that most of the few remaining allegations reveal irregularities and other forms of election misconduct.

00:41:50.657 --> 00:41:55.831
Numerous other studies, including one commissioned by the Trump administration, have reached the same conclusion.

00:41:56.420 --> 00:42:10.380
So, in summary, there is no evidence to prove any of his claims, but in Donald Trump's presidential-sized tantrum he threw to hold onto power, he has eroded one of the most important components of our democracy, and this is just one of the reasons folks are screaming.

00:42:10.380 --> 00:42:13.650
Donald Trump is an existential threat to democracy.

00:42:13.650 --> 00:42:18.766
Political scientists all over, who study democracies, including the rise and fall of them, have been telling us this for years.

00:42:18.766 --> 00:42:23.146
Guys, I've found a lot of these sources and articles are back from 2020, 2021.

00:42:23.146 --> 00:42:27.467
No one should be surprised by this anymore, but weirdly enough, I don't feel like it's being said.

00:42:27.467 --> 00:42:31.503
Well, I feel like we're hearing this, like he's an existential threat, but like no one is.

00:42:31.684 --> 00:42:43.184
I mean, there's just so much that's happening and it's like how can you even keep up with all the way he's threatening things around us?

00:42:43.204 --> 00:42:43.887
Yeah, exactly how can you keep up?

00:42:43.887 --> 00:42:50.547
So, moving on to the second main component of our backslide, and that is the executive overreach, aka, the president has gained too much power in regards to our balance of power among our three branches of government.

00:42:50.547 --> 00:43:04.443
The report explains that even a legitimately elected leader can become an autocrat by consolidating power, via reducing the independence of the civil service and by undermining the checks and balances provided by the legislature and judicial system.

00:43:04.443 --> 00:43:10.422
The civil service is essential to good governance and is a critical component of modern democratic practice.

00:43:10.422 --> 00:43:21.887
The civil service are the folks employed by the government that are not elected, so think workers at government agencies like the DOJ or FDA.

00:43:21.887 --> 00:43:33.447
These workers and agencies collect and release vitally important data that citizens use to assess whether politicians are doing a good job, so things like the unemployment rate, government spending figures, etc.

00:43:33.447 --> 00:43:40.389
Because of this, it is critical that government agencies in charge of reporting this type of data are not corrupted by partisan considerations.

00:43:40.931 --> 00:43:49.711
Now hang in here with us guys, because this gets really in the weeds here a bit, but it's so important to understand how Trump really did make power grabs while in office and how he plans to do so even more in the future.

00:43:49.711 --> 00:43:53.789
We're just going to read this next paragraph directly from the Brookings report.

00:43:53.789 --> 00:44:03.530
It states to an unprecedented degree, the Trump administration and its allies sought to delegitimize, incapacitate and politicize the independent civil service.

00:44:03.530 --> 00:44:10.688
Throughout his term, and as part of his attempted election subversion, president Trump pressured and fired senior officials in the Justice Department.

00:44:10.688 --> 00:44:16.289
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Trump administration interfered with the health reports provided by the Centers for Disease Control.

00:44:16.509 --> 00:44:19.791
Civil servants at every level of government experienced retaliation when their work did not comport with the health reports provided by the Centers for Disease Control.

00:44:19.791 --> 00:44:23.635
Civil servants at every level of government experienced retaliation when their work did not comport with the claims or preferences of the administration.

00:44:23.635 --> 00:44:29.092
Entire offices were relocated to distant cities, forcing employees to uproot their families or quit.

00:44:29.092 --> 00:44:37.670
Attacks on the honesty of individual election officials, health officials and others became commonplace, in some cases provoking threats of violence against them.

00:44:37.670 --> 00:44:41.771
Shortly before the 2020 election, president Trump released an executive order.

00:44:41.771 --> 00:44:49.344
In quotes here, the executive order was Schedule F intended to give him the authority to fire as many as 50,000 career civil servants.

00:44:49.344 --> 00:44:56.871
Preparations are underway to continue this process of power consolidation under a future Republican president, whether or not that president is Trump.

00:44:56.871 --> 00:44:59.085
That's directly from the Brookings Institute report.

00:44:59.327 --> 00:45:00.590
That's insanity.

00:45:00.590 --> 00:45:16.007
We're going to get so much more into the plans for this and the impact it would have in future Project 2025 episodes At least that's the plan right now but just know the power the president would have if this is done which we know Trump plans to do is scary.

00:45:16.007 --> 00:45:27.246
Think appointing folks in the FDA who will reverse the approval of Mifepristone as just one example of how easily he will be able to control things with no interference from the courts or legislature.

00:45:27.246 --> 00:45:33.376
So there is this threat at the federal level absolutely, but it's also happening all around us in state legislators.

00:45:33.376 --> 00:45:52.291
Political scientist Jake Grumbach finds that partisan polarization has a minimal role in explaining the state's democratic backsliding, but that Republican control of state governments dramatically reduces states, but that Republican control of state government dramatically reduces states' democratic performance.

00:45:52.813 --> 00:46:10.213
So I threw that piece in there because I think it's important to note that, like we pay so much attention to the federal and we always talk about it, and obviously it is hugely important to keep Trump out of power but these gerrymandered GOP-controlled states are the ones that are backsliding on the democracy scale too, which I just think is so important to note.

00:46:10.514 --> 00:46:10.956
Definitely.

00:46:11.599 --> 00:46:14.403
So we'll leave you with this in regards to the threat to our democracy.

00:46:14.403 --> 00:46:22.034
In the words of political scientists Daniel Ziblatt and Stephen Levitsky, the electoral road to breakdown is dangerously deceptive.

00:46:22.034 --> 00:46:23.235
People still vote.

00:46:23.235 --> 00:46:27.934
Elected autocrats maintain a veneer of democracy while eviscerating its substance.

00:46:27.934 --> 00:46:34.981
Many government efforts to subvert democracy are legal in the sense that they are approved by legislature or accepted by the courts.

00:46:35.603 --> 00:46:37.766
So let's wrap this up.

00:46:37.766 --> 00:46:39.108
We have a lot to wrap up.

00:46:39.108 --> 00:46:40.130
Today.

00:46:40.130 --> 00:46:43.114
We talked about the violence both Trump and MAGA's incite.

00:46:43.114 --> 00:46:51.559
Then we shared several ways Trump has already done damage to this country and our democracy and why he is set up to do even more if he gets another shot at it.

00:46:51.559 --> 00:47:02.360
Lastly, we talked about the state of our democracy and how the MAGA movement, led by Donald Trump, has accelerated our democratic backsliding, based on the research and analysis from political scientists around the world.

00:47:02.760 --> 00:47:05.327
We'll end with this Donald Trump is a threat.

00:47:05.327 --> 00:47:12.739
If you know that and believe that, then we're going to remind you that it's okay to not vote for your party, even outside of this election.

00:47:12.739 --> 00:47:18.128
Our loyalty should not be to a party, but to the candidate that will best represent us this year.

00:47:18.128 --> 00:47:21.594
In this case, we have to vote for the candidate that will defend our democracy.

00:47:21.594 --> 00:47:29.887
So, when 2028 rolls around, you have the opportunity to vote for a candidate that aligns more with your values, as opposed to not voting.

00:47:29.887 --> 00:47:39.045
Just to be clear, we have to throw away our pride, our egos, our party loyalties, whatever it is that makes us get defensive or want to stick to what we've always done.

00:47:39.427 --> 00:47:47.302
Political parties have a place in democracy, but we're at a point in American politics where these political parties and these candidates are nowhere near comparable or the same.

00:47:47.302 --> 00:47:57.971
Whether you're a Democrat, independent, conservative or you don't want to pick a label, but you're concerned about our country and want an administration that will ensure our democracy is upheld, then make sure you plan to vote this fall.

00:47:57.971 --> 00:48:01.170
And if you're specifically conservative, I want to say something to you right now.

00:48:01.170 --> 00:48:14.351
If you want your party back, we believe the best way to do that is to raid your party of this hatred and extremism that is Donald Trump and mega politicians, and to do that, you have to show up at the ballot box and show them they can't win on the ballot.

00:48:14.351 --> 00:48:21.135
You have to show them that Americans, no matter their political party or views, will not stand for what Donald Trump is and what him and his movement plan to do.

00:48:21.456 --> 00:48:22.996
Thank you, guys, so much for tuning in this week.

00:48:22.996 --> 00:48:27.025
Now more than ever, please, please, please, share this information with your friends and your family.

00:48:27.025 --> 00:48:28.550
We hope you feel equipped to do so.

00:48:28.550 --> 00:48:33.465
You can talk to them about it or you can send them content like this, this episode, in fact.

00:48:33.465 --> 00:48:39.170
It's easy for folks to live in echo chambers, and sharing this type of information really does make a difference.

00:48:39.170 --> 00:48:44.257
Some days, it feels easy to feel helpless or hopeless in this fight, but we are not either of those things.

00:48:44.257 --> 00:48:50.751
We'll leave you with this quote from George Washington Truth will ultimately prevail where there are pains taken to bring it to light.

00:48:50.751 --> 00:48:53.773
Thank you, guys, so much for tuning in this week and we'll catch you next week.

00:48:53.773 --> 00:48:54.619
Thanks y'all.

00:48:54.900 --> 00:48:55.501
We got this.

00:48:55.501 --> 00:49:05.371
Thanks for joining us for today's episode.

00:49:05.371 --> 00:49:06.972
We really appreciate the support.

00:49:07.614 --> 00:49:12.369
We would also really appreciate it if you hit the follow button and share this episode with anyone you think would enjoy it.

00:49:12.882 --> 00:49:15.646
And we'd like to thank Kevin Tanner, who edited this episode.

00:49:15.646 --> 00:49:20.891
If you're interested in learning more about him and his services, his website and Instagram are in the show notes.

00:49:21.400 --> 00:49:22.585
With that, we'll see you next week.

00:49:34.702 --> 00:49:36.248
The Republican Party as folks.

00:49:36.248 --> 00:49:43.224
Well, the Republican Party as folks, whoa Okay, the Republican Party.

00:49:43.224 --> 00:49:44.846
I can't even say it, thank you.

00:49:44.885 --> 00:49:45.367
Kevin and.

00:49:57.210 --> 00:49:57.771
It's who we are.

00:49:57.771 --> 00:49:59.514
Oh, okay, okay, yep, that was helpful, thank you.

00:49:59.514 --> 00:50:02.943
We tell you all this to say.

00:50:02.943 --> 00:50:07.293
I just slapped my desk to make a point.

00:50:07.293 --> 00:50:10.469
There is also evidence.

00:50:10.469 --> 00:50:13.068
There's also evidence that he donated.

00:50:13.068 --> 00:50:14.784
You added this.

00:50:14.784 --> 00:50:18.539
Yeah, I know, I have no one to blame but myself.

00:50:18.539 --> 00:50:30.556
Those were the desensitization, desensitization, itation, oh my god.

00:50:30.556 --> 00:50:35.849
Negative ghost rider.

00:50:36.311 --> 00:50:38.074
Well, I'll tell you have to tell everyone about it.

00:50:38.074 --> 00:50:50.143
So also, by the way, I did it until I did the research for this yes, of course ash.

00:50:50.184 --> 00:50:53.047
We all remember sharpie gay in 2019.

00:50:53.047 --> 00:50:56.512
Okay, I said that weird Democracy.

00:50:56.512 --> 00:50:58.735
Are you from New Jersey, I don't know, or Boston?

00:51:01.139 --> 00:51:03.409
What if I said it every time in an episode like that?

00:51:03.409 --> 00:51:05.222
That was just like my thing.

00:51:05.222 --> 00:51:06.786
Okay, I think you should do it.

00:51:06.786 --> 00:51:09.192
Rest in peace.

00:51:09.192 --> 00:51:16.853
Sorry, I honestly almost paused because I was expecting you to do something, but I was not really expecting that.

00:51:18.141 --> 00:51:19.505
Girl you mentioned Ruth.

00:51:19.505 --> 00:51:21.009
I know I was expecting something.

00:51:21.369 --> 00:51:28.068
I know, so if we didn't make it abundantly clear, oh my God, fuck me.

00:51:29.592 --> 00:51:30.536
Abundantly clear.